bbk 000000

UDC 347.9:502.65

Rozental O. M., Averbukh A. I.

The procedure of arbitration water control

Summary

Measurement errors cause unavoidable differences between the actual and measured values of the investigated water parameters; from whence it is not possible to guarantee different laboratories, e.g. industrial and public water control, getting identical results. The procedure of evaluating and comparing the risks of getting false water quality reports by the two independent parties is suggested. On the basis of the procedure a method of resolving arbitration cases was developed provided the measurement results being compatible. Possible accounting for non-compatible results is considered including the use of reserve samples of the investigated water, standard samples or reference laboratories. Complete elimination of arbitration cases requires carrying out quality control by a single party concerned. It is shown that in this case the proper control is ensured on condition that «the principle of distributed priorities» is applied.

Key words

potable water quality , measurement inaccuracy , water control , environmental protection , laboratory analysis , arbitration

The further text is accessible on a paid subscription.
For authorisation enter the login/password.
Or subscribe

SPISOK LITERATURY

1. GOST R 8.563-2009. GSI. Metodiki (metody) izmerenii.
2. GOST 27384-2002. Voda. Normy pogreshnosti izmerenii pokazatelei sostava i svoistv.
3. Rozental' O. M., Averbukh A. I. Otsenka sootvetstviia kachestva vod ustanovlennym trebovaniiam // Voda: khimiia i ekologiia. 2010. № 11.
4. MI 23-74. Metodika ekspertizy normativov tochnosti v proektakh standartov na syr'e i materialy i na sposoby ispytanii ikh khimicheskogo sostava i fiziko-khimicheskikh svoistv. Sopostavlenie normativov i interpretatsiia rezul'tatov. – M.: Izdatel'stvo standartov, 1975.
5. Shaevich A. B. Analiticheskaia sluzhba kak sistema. – M.: Khimiia, 1981.
6. GOST 8.051-81. GSI. Pogreshnosti, dopuskaemye pri izmerenii lineinykh razmerov.
7. RMG 63-2003. GSI. Obespechenie effektivnosti izmerenii pri upravlenii tekhnologicheskimi protsessami. Metrologicheskaia ekspertiza tekhnicheskoi dokumentatsii.
8. Tartakovskii D. F., Iastrebov A. S. Metrologiia, standartizatsiia i tekhnicheskie sredstva izmerenii. – M.: Vysshaia shkola, 2001.
9. GOST R ISO 5725, chasti 1–6. Tochnost' (pravil'nost' i pretsizionnost') metodov i rezul'tatov izmerenii.
10. PND F 14.1:2:4.135-98 (izdanie 2008 g.). Metodika vypolneniia izmereniia massovykh kontsentratsii metallov metodom atomno-emissionnoi spektrometrii s induktivno sviazannoi plazmoi v pit'evoi, prirodnoi, stochnoi vodakh i atmosfernykh osadkakh.
11. Metodicheskie ukazaniia po razrabotke normativov kachestva vody vodnykh ob"ektov rybokhoziaistvennogo znacheniia, v tom chisle normativov predel'no dopustimykh kontsentratsii vrednykh veshchestv v vodakh vodnykh ob"ektov rybokhoziaistvennogo znacheniia (Utv. prikazom Federal'nogo agentstva po rybolovstvu ot 18 ianvaria 2010 g. № 20).
12. Ponomareva L. S. Ekonomicheskii mekhanizm okhrany vod ot zagriazneniia // Vodosnabzhenie i san. tekhnika. 2010. № 4, № 6, № 7.
13. Dzhonson N., Lion F. Statistika i planirovanie eksperimenta v tekhnike i nauke. Metody obrabotki dannykh. – M.: Mir, 1980.
14. Smirnov N. V., Dunin-Barkovskii I. V. Kurs teorii veroiatnostei i matematicheskoi statistiki dlia tekhnicheskikh prilozhenii. – M.: Nauka, 1965.
15. GOST R 52180-2003. Voda pit'evaia. Opredelenie soderzhaniia elementov metodom inversionnoi vol'tamperometrii.
16. SanPiN 2.1.4.1074-01. Pit'evaia voda i vodosnabzhenie naselennykh mest. Pit'evaia voda. Gigienicheskie trebovaniia k kachestvu vody tsentralizovannykh sistem pit'evogo vodosnabzheniia. Kontrol' kachestva.
17. Rozno M. I., Zil'berbrand G. E. Sertifikatsiia produktsii // Metody otsenki sootvetstviia. 2009. № 12.